Papa's Pizza Grotto Menu (Update 2026)

Cotto and dry salami, mortadella, and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, and onions on a hot Italian roll. Topped with oil and herbs.

Cotto, and dry salami, mortadella, ham, capicola, and provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, and onions on a hot Italian roll. Topped with salad oil and herbs.

Boneless hickory-smoked ham - topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, and herbs on a toasted Italian roll.

Our homemade Italian sausage baked on a hot Italian roll and smothered in meat sauce.

A family favorite! Our sausage sandwich with lightly roasted bell peppers.

Add lightly roasted bell peppers to with meatball sandwich. Delicious!

This Italian classic is made from trimmed pork shoulder, rolled in crushed red pepper, paprika, other herbs, then smoked. Served on a toasted Italian roll topped with lettuce, onion, tomato, oil, and herbs.

Turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, oil, and herbs with mayo on a toasted Italian roll.

Provolone cheese with lettuce, tomato, onion, oil, and herbs. Served on a toasted Italian roll.

Thin crust, house made marinara, 6 large slices. Topping Choice: Pepperoni and/or Sausage only.

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Canadian bacon, bacon, red sauce.

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Canadian bacon, bacon, red sauce.

Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Canadian bacon, bacon, red sauce.

Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, bell pepper, black olive, onion, meatball.

Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, bell pepper, black olive, onion, meatball.

Cheese, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, bell pepper, black olive, onion, meatball.

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom (anchovies or onions).

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom (anchovies or onions).

Cheese, pepperoni, sausage, mushroom (anchovies or onions).

Cheese, mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives.

Cheese, mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives.

Cheese, mushroom, onion, bell pepper, black olives.

Thin crust, marinara, fresh tomato, fresh basil, easy mozzarella, Romano, spices.

Thin crust, marinara, fresh tomato, fresh basil, easy mozzarella, Romano, spices.

Thin crust, marinara, fresh tomato, fresh basil, easy mozzarella, Romano, spices.

Garlic, olive oil, ricotta, mozzarella, romano, fresh basil, spices.

Garlic olive oil, ricotta, mozzarella, Romano, fresh basil, spices.

Canadian bacon, pineapple, garlic, jalapeño, bacon.

Canadian bacon, pineapple, garlic, jalapeño, bacon.

Canadian bacon, pineapple, garlic, jalapeño, bacon.

Can be just a great Cheese Pizza or you and completely customize this pizza to your liking.

Can be just a great Cheese Pizza or you and completely customize this pizza to your liking.

Can be just a great Cheese Pizza or you can completely customize this pizza to your liking.

Serves 2... Can just be a great Cheese Calzone for you and completely customize this pizza to your liking.

Romaine and iceberg lettuce topped with dry salami, mortadella, capicola, red cabbage, tomato, green olive, cucumber, pepperoncini, garbanzo beans, and sharp provolone. Served with Italian dressing. Serves 1-3.

Romaine and iceberg lettuce topped with dry salami, mortadella, capicola, red cabbage, tomato, green olive, cucumber, pepperoncini, garbanzo beans, and sharp provolone. Served with Italian dressing. Serves 2-4.

Iceberg and romaine lettuce garnished with: red cabbage, tomatoes, green olives, pepperoncini's, and cucumbers. Served with your choice of dressing. Feeds 1-2.

Iceberg and romaine lettuce garnished with: red cabbage, tomatoes, green olives, pepperoncini's, and cucumbers. Served with your choice of dressing. Feeds 2-4.

Fresh romaine lettuce garnished with: pepperoncini's, tomatoes, croutons, and freshly grated Pecorino Romano cheese. Serves 1-2.

Fresh romaine lettuce garnished with: pepperoncini's, tomatoes, croutons, and freshly grated Pecorino Romano cheese. Serves 2-4.

Our lettuce and tomato salad topped with mozzarella, ham, turkey, and capicola. Served with your choice of dressing.

An Italian staple! Fresh vegetables, beans, and pasta in an herb-infused tomato broth. Topped with Pecorino Romano cheese.

Generous portion of imported spaghetti served with your choice of meat or vegetarian marinara sauce.

twelve beef and cheese ravioli with your choice of meat or marinara sauce.

Small tube-shaped pasta - great with any of our sauces!

A smaller portion of imported spaghetti served with your choice of meat or vegetarian marinara sauce.

A smaller portion our homemade lasagna that's built with layers of imported and domestic cheeses and topped with your choice of meat or vegetarian marinara sauce.

Twelve beef ravioli with your choice of meat or marinara sauce.

Our homemade lasagna is built with layers of imported and domestic cheeses and topped with your choice of meat or vegetarian marinara sauce.

six beef ravioli with your choice of meat or marinara sauce.

A smaller portion of our large tube-shaped pasta - great with meat sauce!

Twelve cheese ravioli with your choice of meat or vegetarian marinara sauce.

Large tube-shaped pasta - great with meat sauce!

A more classic gluten tree alternative tor the pasta lovers!

six cheese ravioli with your choice of meat or vegetarian marinara sauce.

A smaller portion of our small tube-shaped pasta - great with any of our sauces!

Fettucine Pasta no to be confused for automatic Alfredo sauce. Add many choices of sauces and proteins

Our Housemade alfedo made from scratch per order: using freshly grated pecorino romano. Topped over a generous portion of perfectly cooked Fettuccine noodles.

Beef ravioli paired with lasagna. Choice of meat, marinara, Alfredo, pesto cream, pink cream sauces or no sauce.

Cheese ravioli paired with lasagna, customizable with sauce options including meat, marinara, alfredo, pesto cream, pink cream, or sauce-free.

Spaghetti and lasagna combo with choice of meat, marinara, Alfredo, pesto, pink cream sauces, or served without sauce.

Beef ravioli paired with spaghetti. Choose from meat sauce, marinara, Alfredo, pesto cream, pink cream, or opt for no sauce.

Spaghetti/lasagna/ravioli

spaghetti/lasagna/ravioli

partially naked served drizzled with ranch and Buffalo

Italian Roll sliced and dipped in meat sauce. Smothered with mozzarella and pepperoni.

Our fresh Italian sausage with meat sauce.

Our famous Homemade baseball sized Meatball with Meat Sauce

Our sourdough garlic bread topped with mozzarella cheese and served with marinara tor dipping.

Thick sliced sourdough bread toasted on our oven bricks and covered in garlic butter.

Garlic Bread made on our split Italian Roll

Soft, freshly baked Italian bread roll, served with a side of butter.

8 oz.

Charge for extra dressing with your order.

7 Pieces

7 Pieces

3 oz.

3 oz. cup.

Cannoli with chocolate & nuts filling.

Rich three-layer chocolate cake with creamy chocolate frosting between each layer, topped with chocolate shavings.

Rich and creamy classic New York-style cheesecake, with a buttery graham cracker crust.

Layers of mascarpone cream and espresso-soaked ladyfingers, topped with a dusting of cocoa powder.

Pure and refreshing bottled water.

Cheese pizza with choice of original or thin crust.

Spaghetti served with choice of meat or marinara sauce. Includes bread and optional minestrone soup or salad dressed with a variety of house options.

Lasagna served with choice of meat or marinara sauce. Includes side of minestrone soup or salad with various dressing options such as house bleu-Italian, ranch, or Caesar.

Pepperoni pizza bread. Choice of side: soup or salad with various dressing options including house bleu-Italian, Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, 1,000 island, or Caesar.

Cheese pizza bread served with choice of side: soup or salad with various dressing options including house bleu-Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, 1,000 island, and Caesar.

6" meatball sandwich paired with mozzarella. Choice of side: soup, salad (multiple dressing options including house bleu-Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, 1,000 Island, Caesar).

6" sausage sandwich topped with mozzarella. Choice of side: undressed, minestrone soup, salad (house bleu-Italian, Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, 1,000 island, Caesar dressing).

6" ham sandwich served with provolone. Choice of side: soup (minestrone) or salad with various dressings (house bleu-Italian, Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, 1,000 island, Caesar).

6" Capicola Sandwich with provolone. Choice of side: minestrone soup, salad (multiple dressing options).

6" turkey sandwich with provolone and mayo. Choice of side: soup, salad with various dressings including house bleu-Italian, ranch, bleu cheese, 1,000 island, Caesar.

6" cheese sandwich served with choice of side: soup, salad (various dressings available).